Regarding the 9 Arrested for Attempting To Offer the Korban Pesach Sheini Sacrifice on the Temple Mount

altarFull details of the story about how a group tried to smuggle a goat into the Temple Mount can be found at this link https://www.theyeshivaworld.com/news/israel-news/2397765/nine-arrested-attempting-to-bring-korban-pesach-on-har-habayis-for-pesach-sheini-video.html

A Video of the Event

Background

In the Biblical book of Bamidbar (Numbers) Chapter 9 we learn the following (Koren Jerusalem Bible translation at Sefaria.org):

The Chafetz Chaim in Likutei Halachot, Pesachim, Chapter 7, (on page 80 of the Masechet) Torat Hakodshim, points 30 & 40 implies that only if the Passover sacrifice was observed under the proper conditions in the Hebrew month of Nissan, would the minority have the opportunity (under the proper conditions) to observe the second Passover on the 14th of the second Hebrew month, Iyar.

If you go by his ruling, we could not bring the second Passover sacrifice on the 14th of Iyar.

Rabbi Avraham Y. Kook
Rabbi Avraham Y. Kook

It is brought in the book “Hamikdash Oro Shel Olam” (The Temple is the light of the world) that Rabbi Kook tried to convince the British to allow the renewal of the sacrificial service on the Temple Mount.

The author S. Y. Agnon: Maran Rabbi Kook planned the renewal of the bringing the sacrifices

In the discussion on ‘Prayer in Israel’, which took place at Bar Ilan University, Prof. Dov Sadan (recipient of the Israel Literature Prize 5728 / 1968) described his conversation with the writer S. Y. Agnon regarding the renewal of the sacrificial work and the opinion of Maran Rabbi Kook zt”l on this matter. These are his words[2]

“We must not forget the impact of the assumption of the renewal of sacrifices upon the thinking of the Chibat Zion movement (such as Rabbi Tzvi Hirsch Kalisher and Rabbi Eliyahu Guttmacher). And the position of Rabbi Avraham Yitzchak HaCohen Kook, peace be upon him, will prove that not only did he dream all his days about renewing the sacrifices, and he prepared himself for it, but he sought to make it into reality. And I heard from S.Y. Agnon, that two persons hindered him, the one who did not understand the urgency of the matter – is Chaim Weizmann, and the one who understood the urgency of the matter is Ronald Storrs [the British governor of Jerusalem] and the rabbi felt that this was the point of decisive tragedy in his life” (Rabbi Ari Yitzchak Shevat in his article: ‘The sacrifices of the future in the Third Temple according to Rabbi Kook’).

Prof. Weizmann was one of the leaders of the Zionist Organization and had a decisive influence on the organization and the budgets, but he was distant from the Torah and mitzvot, and therefore treated Rabbi Kook zt”l’s initiative in this matter coldly. On the other side stood Ronald Storrs, the British governor of Jerusalem who sided with the Arabs in the conflict with the Jews. Ronald Storrs was accused of having supported behind the scenes the Arab riots against the Jews in the Jewish year 5680, and remained inactive when faced with the murder of Jews in the settlements of the country. Due to his attitude towards the Jews, Rabbi Kook refused to shake his hand in one case, since, as the governor of Jerusalem, he did many things to favor the Arabs for control of the city and the Temple Mount.

Talks with the authorities regarding the possibility of resuming work at the Temple

Despite the above, it is clear from the testimony of S.Y. Agnon that there was a discussion on this matter with both Prof. Weizmann and Ronald Storrs. This is also evident from the obituaries that were given for Maran Rabbi Kook zt”l on the day of his death, the speakers and writers mentioned among their words his plan to begin the sacrificial service. It turns out that this fact was known not only to S.Y. Agnon but also to journalists. This is how it appears in the newspaper ‘Davar’ (4 Elul 5695) – the newspaper of the workers of Eretz Yisrael, where it was written the day after the death and before Rabbi Kook was buried on the Mount of Olives:

“On his return from London to the Land of Israel after the Balfour Declaration… Rabbi Kook thought of renewing the sacrifices on the Temple Mount, and founded a special yeshiva called ‘Torat Kohanim’, to learn the laws of sacrifices. It is said that General Storrs stressed the politics and the risk about this suggestion and Rabbi Kook ceased to press for the idea”.

In other words, the fact that the talks were held in this matter was a well-known fact, but the special circumstances of the time, such as the tension between Jews and Arabs, as well as the existence of a hostile government in Israel, led Maran, Rabbi Avraham Y. Kook zt”l to the decision to wait for another opportunity. Thus, the idea of ​​renewing the commandments connected to the Temple were pushed away to the period when the people of Israel would rule the Temple Mount, (here ends the excerpt from, “Hamikdash Oro Shel Olam”.

The Justification Offered by the Chozrim LaHar (Return to the Mount) Movement for the Activists Described Above (Translation from their Facebook Page)

The Struggle Over the Passover Sacrifice Escalates
For the first time in two thousand years: A live young goat was brought into the Temple Mount — with the intention of offering it as a Second Passover sacrifice.

Several activists were arrested after being violently attacked by police, Waqf guards, and Arab rioters.

The “Return to the Mount” movement stated:

“The only way to defeat Hamas, free all the hostages, and eradicate terrorism is through a brave return to the Temple Mount. No more dealing with peripheral matters — but full sovereignty, the renewal of sacrificial worship, and the rebuilding of the Temple. Only this way will we prevail.”

Comment by the editor: Even the Return to the Mount movement understands that there are a number of halachic conditions needed in order to restore the sacrificial service that cannot be solved by isolated individuals. It seems to me they are trying to create the political atmosphere that will encourage the politicians to support, restoration of the Temple activities.
Yechezkel's Vision of the Temple According to the Gaon